Cittadinanzattiva has a more than 30 year experience in the protection of citizens' rights in the health sector, which initiated with its Tribunale per i diritti del malato ("Tribunal for Patients' Rights" or TDM) in 1980 and was later strengthened through the Coordinamento nazionale Associazioni Malati Cronici (National Coordination Centre of Chronic Patients' Associations) in 1996.
Over the last 20 years, it has been increasing its contributions for the promotion and protection of citizens' right against useless pain though the following strategic actions:
Protection against violations of the right of individual citizens, trough its free-of-charge counselling, information and support service provided by 300 TDM offices located nationwide.
Collection and dissemination of best practices with many editions of national prizes on humanization and pain.
Promotion of information and awareness raising campaigns for the citizenry.
Actions designed to promote cultural changes, though panels organised with health workers, health corporations, institutional representatives; national conferences on pain (5 conferences as of today's date with an annual frequency; a "Surgery Quality Charter" and an "Internal Medicine Quality Charter").
Institutional mediation, aimed at strengthening the protection of rights (e.g. the 2008 Civil Recommendation on Non-Oncologic Chronic Pain, its action in favour of the abolition of the special prescription pad for narcotics, and the promotion of pain-free hospice care).
Production of citizens' information, i.e. information directly produced by citizens, "based on their point of view, starting from the data directly or indirectly acquired and meant for changing the current state of affairs with a view to effectively improving the protection of citizens' rights and achieving conditions for effective protection" by means of follow-ups, enquiries and citizens' audits.
A few of Cittadinanzattiva's promoted and implemented initiatives
1997/ongoing National Prizes on Pain
Over the years, Cittadinanzattiva has established specific national awards for the humanization of medical treatment and fight against pain:
- the “Andrea Alesini Award for the humanization of care” in which pain management is an important issue;
- the “National Prize on Chronic Pain Nottola - Mario Luzi”, organized by Cittadinanzattiva-Tuscany.
2002 - "Let us abolish forced pain"
This citizen information campaign on pain was organised and promoted in 2001. Its fundamental objective was dispelling any false myths on the tolerability and incurability of pain for a few population groups in particular (e.g. the elderly), and discussing the prescriptibility of narcotics.
2005 - "Charter of Rights against Unnecessary Pain"
The Charter of Rights against Unnecessary and Useless Pain was first promoted by Cittadinanzattiva in 2005. Its objective is to declare and protect a group of rights, 8 in total, that are still often violated and consequently obtain treatment in order to remedy e.g. the sufferance felt at any time of a disease -by the elderly, children, etc. – in the performance of invasive examinations (so that reported pain will not be minimesed, but rather into account and suitably treated), to only quote an example.
2008 - "We are not born to suffer" Campaign
This awareness raising campaign was promoted in 2008 though the creation of info points in the squares of 40 Italians cities. Its objectives included: to supply communication instruments to facilitate dialogue between physician and patients and to favour opportunities between healthcare workers and all professionals involved in the diagnostic and treatment of chronic pain.
"Against Useless Pain"
A report on the respect of the 2005 Charter of Rights. A few activists of Cittadinanzattiva monitored the state of implementation of the Charter of Rights against Useless Pain in 33 Italian hospitals and health centres, by involving citizens and healthcare workers.
2008 -Civil Recommendation on Non-oncologic Chronic Pain
The Recommendation is the result of dialogue between citizens and experts in matters related to pain treatment over 3 days of workshop organised in 2008. Its purpose was to make a real contribution for the development of protection policies intended to overcome the main criticalities identified in the treatment of non-oncologic chronic pain. It was called "civil" as it originates from the choice of enhancing the "citizen's standpoint" in the identification of action to be recommended to each institution, organisation or person concerned with pain treatment. The contents of the Recommendation were also reproduced in law no. 38/2010.
2010/ongoing Implementation of the Italian Law 38/2010
Our direct involvement & contribution with data in drafting the National Report written by the Ministry of Health to the Parliament on the state of implementation of the Italian Law 38/2010, that assures the citizens' right to have access to palliative care and to antalgic centres in case of either oncologic or non-oncologic pain. Download the Annual report 2010 and 2011 (IT language).
Last 7th of June 2016, Cittadinanzattiva presented his document, from the patients’ point of view, about the implementation of the Law 38/2010 on chronic pain, during an hearing of the Committee for Palliative Care and Pain Therapy of the Italian Ministry of Health. Read the document (IT language).
2010 - "We are not born to suffer, Chronic pain and healthcare experiences". Campaign
With the direct involvement of general practitioners, managers of pain treatment centres, patients treated at these centres and chronic patients, the requirement were identified of persons suffering from chronic pain, and available healthcare services were examined from a citizen's standpoint; the main faults of the system and – concurrently – example of best practice were also identified.
Another important fact-finding contribution in terms of social and healthcare impact of pain treatment methods on the lives of citizens came from the Annual Pit Salute Reports (1997-2012), the Annual Reports of Cittadinanzattiva's National Coordination Centre of Chronic Patients' Associations, the two Integrated Hoe Care Reports (2006 and 2008), the Oncologic Home Care Report (for years 2004 and 2005), and the Citizens'Audit Report (for years 2000-2010).
2012 - "In-dolore" Campaign
With the Campaign "In-Dolore" (painless), started in the second half of 2012, Cittadinanzattiva wants to dispel taboos and offer advice, information and protection to citizens on what to do and what to expect, at home, from the family doctor, medical facilities, in order to don't suffer needlessly.
The campaign also provides instructions for using the Italian Law n.38 of 2010 which, although unknown to most people, is a law forefront in Europe and defends us from unnecessary pain.
The campaign develops initiatives in many Italian cities, where volunteers of the Tribunal for Patients' Rights will be available to the public, to give information and advice about their rights. During these occasions, will be distributed free the practical guide "In-Dolore" (painless), also available online in the Cittadinanzattiva website.
2014 “In-dolore 2nd Edition” Project
A pilot civic audit in the Italian hospitals about treatment and attention to pain. Promoted by the Tribunal for Patients’ rights and realized in collaboration with the Civic Evaluation Agency to monitor citizens’ perspectives about treatment and attention to pain as well as the presence of fundamental services, features and best practices in the Italian hospitals. Goals of the project were: build a network and promote centres of excellence, draw attention on the topic and encourage a healthy competition among healthcare providers to improve pain treatment on the basis of citizens’ needs. Indeed, the project has informed citizens about attention to pain provided by 46 Hospitals that have voluntarily submitted to: detailed data are available online. 214 wards have been monitored and 711 patients have been interviewed, thanks to the help of our volunteers. Data have been collected through two main tools: a checklist containing 50 items and a questionnaire addressed to patients of 5 key wards. Methodology and results of the project will be officially presented at the European Parliament in April and May. For more details (IT language). In 2016, the project was presented at the EU Parliament as good practice.
2016 - Implementation of the Italian law on chronic pain: the report of Cittadinanzattiva to the Ministry of Health
On the 7th of June Cittadinanzattiva presented his document, from the patients’ point of view, about the implementation of the Law 38/2010 on chronic pain, during an hearing of the Committee for Palliative Care and Pain Therapy of the Italian Ministry of Health. Read the document (in Italian).
2016 - Pain Therapy & Palliative Care: Cittadinanzattiva in the technical committee of the Italian Ministry of Health
In Italy there is a section of the Technical Committee on Health of the Ministry of Health devoted to pain treatment, that is an organization bringing together 204 experts for advice and support in policies covering different areas of health and science. One section in particular focus on palliative care and pain management and the member who represents the citizens' associations is now the national coordinator of the Tribunal for Patients' Rights of Cittadinanzattiva. To Read more (IT language)
A few promoted and implemented initiatives of the European branch of Cittadinanzattiva,
Active Citizenship Network
2002 - The issue of pain in the European Charter of Patients' Rights
The European Charter of Patients' Rights was drafted in 2002 by Active Citizenship Network in collaboration with citizens' & patients organizations from 12 different EU countries. The European Charter of Patients' Rights states 14 patients' rights that together aim to guarantee a "high level of human health protection" (Article 35 of the Charter of fundamental rights of the European Union) and to assure the high quality of services provided by the various national health services in Europe.
The 14 rights are an embodiment of fundamental rights and, as such, they must be recognised and respected in every country. They are correlated with duties and responsibilities that both citizens and health care stakeholders have to assume. The Charter applies to all individuals, recognising the fact that differences, such as age, gender, religion, socio-economic status etc., may influence individual health care needs.
Art.11 of the European Charter of Patients’ Rights clearly establishes the Right to Avoid Unnecessary Suffering and Pain: “Each individual has the right to avoid as much suffering and pain as possible, in each phase of his/her illness”. Read more
2011/ongoing - ACN in the Board of Pain Alliance Europe
The Director of Active Citizenship Network has been elected in the Board Member of PAE-Pain Alliance Europe. He was re-elected during the last General Assembly of PAE celebrated on February 23rd 2016 in Bruxelles. To know more about PAE, click here
2012-2014 – Pain Patient Pathway Recommendations
A three years multi-stakeholder project realized by Active Citizenship Network in partnership with Pain Alliance Europe in 18 European countries. The main objectives were: realize a civic assessment on chronic pain policies in the EU countries; create a greater awareness of chronic pain; promote a European policy on chronic pain and reduce the impact of chronic pain on all areas of European society.
The projects outcomes include the development of the Report on the Assessment of the EU Patient Right of Avoiding Unnecessary Suffering and Pain and the publication of the EU Pain Patient Pathway Recommendations. For further information, please see our website.
2014 - EU civic research: collection of good practices on chronic pain – “Making the invisible visible”
In 2014, Active Citizenship Network realized a research-project at the European level with the aim to give evidence on existing good practices in several European countries in terms of struggle against pain. The aims include raising awareness about the phenomenon, enhancing the body of knowledge of positive experiences and success, and strengthening the commitment to this topic.
The results of the projects were presented in a EU conference “Chronic pain: making the invisible visible. European collection of good practices” on October 2nd, during the Italian EU Semester of Presidency (July-December 2014), in Brussels. The event involved participants from 17 European Countries and from various background (leader of patients' organizations and representatives of health-focused NGO, healthcare professionals and their EU Networks, policymakers from Member States and UE Institutions and public relations agencies). Please see the report and the abstract and the conference programme.
2015/ongoing - "European Civic Prize on Chronic Pain" - Tell us about your way of working with chronic pain and win!
Active Citizenship Network launched the first ”EU Civic Prize on Chronic Pain - Collecting good practices”. The aim is to give evidence of existing good practices in European countries in terms of struggle against pain. We like to think that this will be the first in a series of prizes – perhaps every two years – awarded to celebrate progress in the treatment and manage of chronic pain. The winners will be given an expenses-paid visit to another winner and a publication in English in a suitable journal. Here more information, the project leaflet, the guide and the link to fill the form.
2015/ ongoing – Involvement in “Societal Impact of Pain” (SIP)
In December 2015 the “Societal Impact of Pain” (SIP) has officially included in its Steering Committee the citizens and patients’ points of views by inviting ACN to be part of it. Since SIP Symposium 2016, Active Citizeneship Network is officially recognized as cooperation partner of the initiative.
2016 Sine Dolore Excellence Award”: ACN awarded for his commitment in the fight of unnecessary pain
Active Citizenship Network received the award, promoted by Efhre International University (EIU)and Sine Dolore, in the “Organizaciones Sociales” category for its work against pain. Mariano Votta received the award on the 7th of May during the Closing Gala of the Sine Dolore Pain Meeting in Menorca, Spain. More information here.
2016 - Pain Therapy and the Degree of Patient’s Pain in the Age of Cross-Border Healthcare Conference
Article 8.5 of the Directive 2011/24/EU states that the degree of patient’s pain must be taken into account in the process of the cross-border healthcare treatment authorization. Member States should have transposed the Directive into their national legislation by October 2013 and, consequently, should have put in place mechanisms to assess the patient's level of pain. The conference, hosted in the framework of the EU Parliamentary Interest Group "European Patients' Rights & Cross-Border Healthcare", aimed to underline how the protection of patients' rights seeking care abroad is also related to an effective implementation of those aspects of the Directive that may be seen of little importance, such as, for example, the reference to pain intensity. Pain intensity is not a secondary issue at all; it can facilitate the building of a European network of specialised centres or centres of excellence on pain therapy, which may host patients from other countries, in accordance with the hopes revealed during the Italian Presidency of the Council of the European Union, in the second half of 2014. To read more
- International & National initiatives for the European Patients’Rights Day
- Polart Circle
- Celebrated in Nicosia the Final International Conference of the European Project Patients’ Voice
- Improving patients’ rights in the age of the Cross Border Healthcare Directive
- The involvement of Active Citizenship Network in SIP 2017
- Improving patients’ rights in the age of the Cross Border Healthcare Directive
- EUROPEAN PATIENTS’ RIGHTS DAY 2017 - BIOGRAPHIES
- From Citizen Involvement to Policy Impact (U-Impact)
- EUROPEAN PATIENTS’ RIGHTS DAY 2017 - PROGRAMME
- Active for Young Professionals
- Pain Euro-Mediterranean Coalition
- Joint Citizen Action for a Stronger, Citizen-Friendly Union (JoiEU)
- EUROPEAN PATIENTS’ RIGHTS DAY 2017
- European Charter of Active Citizenship
- EXPLORING AREAS AND BENEFITS OF COOPERATION IN CROSS-BORDER HEALTHCARE TO PROTECT PATIENTS’ RIGHTS
Read all >